5 Best Electric Ice Cream Maker Reviews And Other FAQs 2021

If you are looking at an electric ice cream maker for yourself, your family or even as a present for friends then be assured that they are an excellent addition to any home.

Homemade ice cream is one of the guilty pleasures that you are allowed. It is not only better for you than most of the commercial brands out there, but if you plan well, it can also be much cheaper to make your own. So how do you decide which electric ice cream maker is right for you? Well the first things you must take into consideration is whether you want it to be

  • Completely Automatic
  • Hand Crank

2 Types of Electric Ice Cream Makers

Automatic Electric Ice Cream Makers

If you go completely automatic, you are probably looking at spending a little bit more, but you literally just throw in your mixture and away you go. You do nothing else and hey presto maybe an hour later you get great ice cream. If you are not making your own homemade ice cream for the physical pleasure and involvement then go for one of the fully automatic electric ice cream makers.

Hand Crank

A hand crank ice cream maker involves more input from you (or your kids) as you do have to do all the churning yourself. It is a more romantic way of making ice cream, but if standing over a tub churning is not your idea of romance then this is probably not the one for you.

The next decision is whether you want a machine that freezes the bowl for you, or you don’t mind freezing the bowl in advance in your own freezer. Again if you are just looking for convenience then having your ice cream maker do the whole job from start to finish is the way to go. But you may be able to keep your cost down by going the ‘freeze your own bowl’ route.

Best Overall

“ICE-70” Electronic ice cream maker by Cuisinart

Cuisinart ICE-70 Electronic Ice Cream Maker, Brushed Chrome, Ice Cream Maker with Countdown Timer, With Countdown Timer

A common issue that those who use ice cream makers deal with regularly is that it is difficult for them to time everything right. If they end the process too early, the ice cream comes out watery. If they end the process too late, the ice cream will end up too hard.

The ICE-70, by Cuisinart, solves this issue by simply containing a countdown timer. This is very useful if you are using it to make ice cream while doing something else. You no longer need to worry about stopping the operation too soon, too late, or worrying about other timing issues.

Another good thing that the ICE-70 contains is a control panel with three multiple speeds. These multiple speeds also utilize the countdown timer, so you will not need to worry about the timing of these different speeds and how they make ice cream either.

However, anybody who is looking to make ice cream for large parties will need to either acquire multiple makers or look for an ice cream maker that can make more than two quarts of ice cream, which is the ICE-70’s maximum capacity.

Something else that you should be aware of is that the freezer bowl of the ICE-70 needs to be frozen for at least 24 hours before it can be placed in the maker. You will need to be patient when using the ICE-70.

Best Budget

4 quart ice cream maker by Hamilton Beach

Hamilton Beach 68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker, 4 Quart, White

If you are looking for an ice cream maker that will make ice cream for large parties, look no further than Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker.

Being able to produce up to 4 quarts of ice cream, you will not have any trouble serving ice cream to large parties with Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker. And the best part is that you do not need to wait forever to make all of this ice cream either. Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker can make 4 quarts of ice cream in 40 minutes.

You will also get a lot out of Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker if you follow a ketogenic diet. It is capable of making ice cream with ingredients that are considered sugar free and grain free, which is something that not a lot of ice cream makers are capable of.

There are a couple of things that you need to watch out for with Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker, however. First, the ingredients can spill outside of the maker. You place the ingredients inside of it like with any other ice cream maker, but instead of being sealed with a top, it is sealed with a brim-type object with two sides. This kind of design can be a bit messy.

Also, because its motor is so strong and because it can make so much ice cream, it is possible that Hamilton Beach’s ice cream maker can stop functioning after so much use. To prevent this, you might need to use it a little less frequently than other ice cream makers.

Best Ice Cream Maker Under $100

“ICE-21” frozen yogurt, ice cream, and sorbet maker by Cuisinart

Cuisinart ICE-21PK Frozen Yogurt - Ice Cream & Sorbet Maker, Pink

Something that can be troublesome when using an ice cream maker is the need to use ice. This can get very messy and it can actually cause inconsistencies in what the ice cream maker will produce. This is because ice melts and it is difficult to know how much ice has melted.

Something that sets Cuisinart’s ICE-21 ice cream maker apart from others in a good way is that it has a double insulated freezer bowl. This not only eliminates the need for ice, but it also means that you do not need to keep the bowl in your freezer for a whole day before getting it ready for the ice maker.

It is a little easier to add ingredients to the ICE-21 than some other ice cream makers. The lid that it comes with locks very easily and the spout is much larger than normal ice cream makers, making it not only easy to add ingredients but much less messy.

Most ice cream makers take 40 minutes to make any given frozen treat that it can make. The ICE-21 does this in half the time, which is much more convenient than waiting close to an hour.

There are a couple of things that you should watch out for with the ICE-21. First, it is designed for smaller crowds, only being able to make 1 and ½ quarts. With most ice cream makers being able to make at least 2 quarts of ice cream, this limits the ICE-21 a little bit.

Best Ice Cream Maker Under $50

Electric ice maker with easy-carry handle by Nostalgia

Nostalgia Electric Ice Cream Maker With Easy-Carry Handle Makes 4-Quarts In Minutes, Frozen Yogurt, Gelato – Blue

It can be difficult to carry around ice cream makers. Most of them need to be carried with two hands, which can be uncomfortable
This is especially true if you want to make ice cream in different locations. It can be a chore to carry it around this way with both hands.

Nostalgia’s ice cream maker solves this problem by containing an easy-carry handle. This eliminates any and all worry about carrying it anywhere.

Another nice thing about Nostalgia’s ice cream maker is its quantity. It can make up to 4 quarts of ice cream, which is nearly twice as much as the average ice cream maker which can only make 2. To make this even better, it only takes about 20 minutes for Nostalgia’s ice cream to finish its process, compared to 40 minutes for most other ice cream makers.

Nostalgia’s ice cream maker contains an aluminum inner bowl for storage purposes. While this is convenient, this aluminum bowl is not very durable. It will cause dents if dropped, and because this inner bowl cannot be removed when ice cream is being made, the deformation will seriously affect how ice cream is made in Nostalgia’s maker.

Best Ice Cream Maker For Home

“ICE-30R” frozen sorbet and ice cream maker by Cuisinart

Cuisinart ICE-30R Pure Indulgence Frozen Yogurt Sorbet & Ice Cream Maker, 2 quart, Brushed Metal/Red

Most ice cream makers exaggerate their claims greatly when they mention that they have a spout that is big enough to add mix-ins. While their spouts are large in their own right, it can be difficult to add most mix-ins.

There are no exaggerations with the ICE-30R, by Cuisinart. Its spout is significantly wider in diameter than most other ice cream makers, and it is easy to add any kind of mix-ins that you want in it.

The ICE-30R also contains an impressive motor that can make ice cream in as short as 25 minutes. This is much shorter than the average ice cream maker that takes upwards of 40 minutes to complete their ice cream making processes.

Another aspect of the ICE-30R that gives it a lot of value is its double-insulated freezer bowl You will not need to worry about your ice cream not being as cold as it should be when using the ICE-30R. The added insulation will ensure that everything is as cold as it needs to be.

Unfortunately, the ICE-30R only has an average capacity of 2 quarts. While this is usually sufficient for average-sized parties, it will be a struggle for large parties to get the most out of the ICE-30R.

How Much Does An Electric Ice Cream Maker Cost?

Medium electric ice cream maker you can get electric ice cream makers for as little as a few dollars, but you can also spend up to several hundred if you are so inclined. The good thing is you don’t have to go that expensive to get a good electric ice cream maker or a solid frozen yogurt machine.

Remember that an ice cream maker should last for many years if you look after it carefully, cleaning it properly after each use and storing it in a safe environment. Take this into consideration when deciding on your budget as some of the less expensive ones are not designed to last, they are just made for some good quick fun and you will need to factor in the cost of replacing them further down the line.

If you are serious about making ice cream then try to stretch your budget to one of the better known more serious brands such as Cuisinart, Rival or White Mountain to name just a few. These machines will make ice cream like the professionals, and few people will be able to tell the difference between your homemade ice cream and the top end commercial ice creams that you pay lots for.

Where Will You Put Your Electric Ice Cream Maker?

Think about what space you have for your new machine. i.e. where are you going to put it and more importantly where are you going to store it when it is not in use. This is important as some of the electric ice cream makers are very big and cumbersome, and too awkward to get out on a regular basis or to have sitting on your countertop full time. So measure up before you get your wallet out.

Finally, you need to think of how much you will use your electric ice cream maker. Is it just going to be used for special occasions and dinner parties? Or do you plan to make it a regular part of your diet? Some ice cream makers take much longer to produce the end product than others, and some involve more work and involvement from you.

This is ok if you are not going to be a regular user, but if you plan on regular use, then it can be a cumbersome and lengthy process if you chose one of the more manual types. So decide on this before you start shopping. Using an electric ice cream maker to make your ice cream is very simple, and is perhaps one of the most rewarding eating experiences.

Some Tips for Using Ice Cream Maker

It is wonderful to produce your own homemade ice cream for dinner parties. You can tailor it to exactly how you want it, taking into account any allergies or dislikes that your guests may have. Not only that, you can make it as delicious and fattening or as healthy and low fat as you want.

And always check that all the parts that come with your ice cream machine are in the box and all in good condition. Don’t wait until you need to use a particular part to discover that it never came (6 months down the line).


Here at Electric Ice Cream Makers – we are all ice cream lovers (no surprise there). Every day our team looks through all the suppliers and their offerings, looking for the best discounts to bring here to our site. For us here, it is also about knowing what you are putting into your ice cream, you can make it as healthy or a sinful if you want. Please enjoy our site, but also we wish you endless hours of fun making Ice Cream.

An interesting fact to impress your friends with: Ice cream headache or more commonly called brain freeze is quite simple really. When your mouth is very warm, like on a warm day, and you put something really cold into it, hitting the roof of your mouth, all the blood vessels in the area try to overcompensate to heat the area up again.

So this is what causes the pain. It doesn’t usually last very long, not more than 20 seconds but more like 5-10. And whether you buy your ice cream or use an electric ice cream maker to produce it, you are still liable to get an ice cream headache.

Recent Posts